I would suggest you to choose a shade that is 1-2 shades lighter than your actual skin tone for highlighting and shades that are 1-2 shades darker than your skin tone for contouring.
I am looking forward to try more shades.
After my first use along with their concealer I was so shocked to see myself with out dark circles for the first time in years! Complete makeup routine by applying the highlighter shade as the last step after foundation.
I have severe under eye dark circles.
However, after putting it on and setting it, it just became cakey and accentuated all my fine lines, looked horrible.
For highlighting: apply a shade 1-2 shades lighter than your foundation on the high points of your face such as the center of your forehead, bridge of the nose, tops of the cheekbones, and under your eyes to brighten.